Redboy / jocko has made more dead game dogs !

[Officially Retired]

even though old SDJ reports clearly show RBJ in the lead in the 90's
.

Actually, that is not even remotely true either.

In fact, in the 90s, Fat Bill (in the editorial of his American Gamedog Times magazine) used to call the Journal "The Jeep/Buck" Journal ... not because RBJ dogs were in there the most ... but because Jeep/Buck (Crenshaw/STP) dogs were in there the most.

I actually think Jeep/Rascal and Eli dogs dominated ... and Boyles dogs were in there a bunch too ... and, of course, RBJ dogs were in there as well. (I mean, hey, it's a great line.)

But your statement "all the good dogs" come from this line is so false it would do everyone some good if you just retracted it

Jack

[waccamaw]

Actually, that is not even remotely true either.

In fact, in the 90s, Fat Bill (in the editorial of his American Gamedog Times magazine) used to call the Journal "The Jeep/Buck" Journal ... not because RBJ dogs were in there the most ... but because Jeep/Buck (Crenshaw/STP) dogs were in there the most.

I actually think Jeep/Rascal and Eli dogs dominated ... and Boyles dogs were in there a bunch too ... and, of course, RBJ dogs were in there as well. (I mean, hey, it's a great line.)

But your statement "all the good dogs" come from this line is so false it would do everyone some good if you just retracted it

Jack

What fat bill was talking about ,jack Kelly and Crenshaw being best of friends ,not to mention who ever spent the most money in the mag with paid adds .i I never said that RBJ were the only good dogs

[Officially Retired]

What fat bill was talking about ,jack Kelly and Crenshaw being best of friends ,not to mention who ever spent the most money in the mag with paid adds .i I never said that RBJ were the only good dogs

You said exactly that. Here is what you said, at the top and bottom of Page 1:

It is a known fact that the redboy / jocko dogs have made more dogs dead game !!

No, but these dogs on average have it all.smarts ,heart ,mouth ,and drive.ever noticed how all the good ones are redboy / jocko or have red boy / jocko in them.

Those are the statements that I, and other, knowledgeable dogmen are having trouble swallowing.

No one is suggesting RBJ dogs aren't good, some truly great.
No one is suggesting that it isn't an all-time great bloodline.

What is being disputed is 1) that this line has made MORE dogs "dead game" than any other (which I assume means killed more dogs than any other), and 2) that "all the good ones" are of this bloodline. They simply are not.

You have made two false statements IMO.

It's not the end of the world ... but it does provide a lot of room for debate

Jack