No, the pedigrees you referenced are different. It's Poncho being bred to Wild Red Rose in one pedigree and Kitana in the other & Thunder was bred to both of those gyps as well. And I understand why those would be different WCI percentages.

BUT, in the pedigrees I'm asking about...

(Bruiser x Belle) x (Ranger x Lil Brook)

and

(Ranger x Lil Brook) x (Bruiser x Belle).

If Bruiser was bred to "Lil Brook" in one of those pedigrees it would be understandable, but he wasn't. So, with the exact genetic make-up why are the WCI's not the same? And I'm not trying to argue, I'm genuinely trying to understand it.