I tried the Diamond naturals extreme athlete chicken and rice formula for for about a month. I wasn't happy with the stools. Some were fine but others just kept shitty mush piles and it stinks up the yard. I agree with you BONEDADDY, the Victor isn't the same feed as it use to be. From what I can find, Victor started using a cheaper protein source in the form of blood mill. Blood mill is used as a plant fertilizer but from what I've seen it's not popular to use in a dog food. Anyway it's something to consider when you realize Victor feed has changed from what it use to be.

https://www.pminutrition.com/product...ice-exclusive/
I've been feeding this feed for a month or so and it is so far everything I'm looking for in a kibble. It's pricy and can only be bought at feed stores and co-op type stores like Victor but if you have access to it then I'd recommend giving it a try. PMI offers a deal to where for every 8 bags you buy, you get the ninth bag Free! I pay $36.32 per #35 bag which is more than Victor or Diamond but I'm getting better results and I don't have to feed as much because it tends to hold my dogs weight better.