Should Showing EXTREME GAMENESS be Part of DOY Candidacy?

[arsuffi@att.net]

I disagree completely that "the better dog won" between Jeep and Homer ...

I can think of a lot of great dogs who lost only because their weight wasn't right, they were brought in underweight/bad condition, etc.

That said, I very much do agree with the general idea of DOY being a title of Most Accomplished dog of the year ... however, isn't showing extreme, 100% dead gameness an accomplishment ... arguably even the most important accomplishment?

Jack

yes