Ok then why would Earl be so happy at Billy second match yelling and carring on? Also dont you think Earl would have said something when Billy was alive? I mean with historical info we do have Earl was alive and well, so to me that does nt make sense to me. If there was paper hanging that went on then do you blame the breeder or the owner who took the breeders word? You have dogs and been around since 87 then i think the most important thing is for one to be happy with whats in ones backyard i assume you are just like me. So in the end how Billy was bred or wasnt has no effect on the dogs we feed today to much time has passed. Yis Ole Man