For me polls like these are apples and oranges. For every great thing Buck did there is a guy will tell you Frisco produced better. And everything Frisco produced is crap compared to Yellow. And there would be no reference to Yellow without mentioning Jocko. And then that guy in the corner will tell you about Redboy owning the game for thirty years. Too many opinions and most of those opinions are based on another person's opinion. I do agree, it is fun reading, but sometimes even fun reading is pointless. It is only a handful of people that personally witnessed these dogs, or even better, actually owned a dog right off them. But there are thousands that will tell you adamantly which is better and why the other is crap.
And as I climb down off the soapbox, I will join the masses. I like Bolio and Redboy. Mostly because some of my best dogs were heavily bred from both of these dogs and then crossed. Since Redboy did not make the list I would vote Bolio 1 and Yellow 2.
And thirdly. I like it when there are explanations behind the choices. Makes for more fun and pointless reading. EWO