Nice writeup, EWO. I think the major problem is that most of us have fallen prey to the dog food manufacturers' marketing. We try to do the best we can for our best friends and they certainly know how to capitalize on our emotions. I actually remember Field Trial. Hard to forget, never seen anything like it. I worked at a boarding kennel in the late 80's and that was their basic kennel food. I guess everyone wants to know what's the best dog food... Sort of like asking what's the best bloodline. I only feed a couple and so cost to me is not a factor. However, if I was feeding many I would certainly try Valu Pak -although it's not available in the Pacific Northwest. Costco has their own basic maintenance brand. About 30 bucks for 50 lbs I think. I wouldn't hesitate to try that either.